Fourth Circuit Rules Maryland Can Regulate Sports Contracts
The prediction market industry picked up another loss from the US Court of Appeals this week.
The Fourth Circuit ruled against Kalshi's request for a temporary injunction against Maryland. As a result, the state can enforce its gambling laws on the platform’s sports prediction markets. The ruling can be appealed to the US Supreme Court, which is already slated to review a similar case from New Jersey.
Unlike rulings Kalshi lost in the Sixth and Ninth Circuits, the Fourth Circuit's three-judge panel split on its decision.
The two judges who ruled against Kalshi agreed that Maryland has the right to regulate sports markets, but only one found that the offering doesn’t qualify as a “swap.” The other judge assumed they were, but ruled the federal laws protecting them weren’t meant to preempt state gambling laws.
Fortunately for Kalshi and the prediction industry, the lone dissenting judge found that sports contracts are “swaps,” meaning states have no right to regulate them. This is the argument the industry has used in court, though many have rejected the claim.
With the ruling delivered, Kalshi must now decide whether to halt sports contracts in Maryland or risk fines and other penalties.
Split Ruling a Bad Omen for Industry
The lack of a unanimous ruling from the Fourth Circuit is a small win for the prediction industry, but it may ultimately be a bad omen for its future.
For over a year, the prediction industry has been insisting that its sports markets are a form of “swaps” protected under the Commodity Exchange Act. This helped prevent state regulation for some time, but that success eventually ran into a major roadblock during the appeals process.
Over the last six months or so, judges have begun to assume that the offering qualifies as “swaps.” However, most have ruled that the CEA’s protection was never meant to preempt state gambling laws, leading them to side with state regulation.
This was on display in the Maryland case, where the two assenting judges delivered similar rulings using two separate lines of logic.
While winning over one judge is a win for Kalshi, the overall result shows the industry will eventually be fighting a two-front war before the nation’s highest court.
Latest Betting Articles
Kalshi Confirms It Will Drop Speech Markets Amid Controversy
1 day ago | Michael Savio
US Senators Step Up Opposition to Sports Prediction Markets
2 days ago | Michael Savio
Louisiana Wins Restraining Order Against Prediction Markets
3 days ago | Michael Savio