Nashville SC vs. New York City FC Prediction: Boys in Gold Aim To Maintain Top Form

Saturday evening will be the last round of fixtures till mid July as we head closer towards the 2026 FIFA World Cup. Nashville SC will welcome New York City FC to Geodis Park. 

• Rolling into Matchday 15, Nashville are the current leaders in the   Supporters’ Shield race 

• NYCFC have only dropped one match from their previous five 

Here, we will break down the betting odds and share our favourite picks for Nashville SC vs. New York City FC.

Nashville SC vs. New York City FC Betting Odds for Saturday, May 23

The hosts are favoured to get into the win column, priced at -145, while the visitors are listed at +350 for the upset. If both sides are level after 90 minutes, the draw is penned in at +280. 

Nashville SC vs. New York City FC Odds

Odds for Nashville SC vs. New York City FC are provided by FanDuel Sportsbook, one of the best World Cup betting sites. Sign up for a FanDuel account and claim your bonus: Bet $5, Get $150 in Bonus Bets. Read more about FanDuel Promo Code here.

If you are in a state where FanDuel is not yet legal, we recommend trying Kalshi, one of the best prediction markets in the US. Sign up using the Kalshi promo code WSN to get a $10 bonus after making 100 contracts.

Nashville SC vs. New York City FC Betting Prediction 

Nashville risks its undefeated home streak this Saturday against fellow Eastern Conference heavyweight NYCFC. We break down the latest betting markets to lock in our top wager for the match.

Nashville SC Preview 

B.J. Callaghan and his men are playing an attractive brand of soccer in 2026, which has led them to the top of the MLS table with 30 points. The Boys in Gold are getting the job done on both sides of the pitch, ranking fourth overall in goals scored per match while conceding only 0.80 goals per match, tied for first overall throughout the competition. 

Nashville suffered a huge blow to its lineup in late April as Sam Surridge suffered an apparent back injury. The team’s leading goal getter will still be on the sidelines watching from afar, but this is a team that is littered with quality players. The previous three matches have seen three different members score at least a pair of goals, as Warren Madrigal, Bryan Acosta, and 2022 MLS Golden Boot winner Hany Mukhtar have stepped up with Surridge’s absence. 

Grab $150 in Bonus Bets With a $5 Correct Bet at FanDuel

New York City FC Preview 

Pascal Jansen and his colleagues have performed better of late, overcoming an ugly stretch that saw them go winless in six consecutive MLS outings. The Pigeons, for the second consecutive time this year, avoided a setback against their Hudson River rivals, NYRB. Saturday’s result saw them share the spoils with second-half substitute Andrés Perea finding the leveller with an accurate header during the 52nd minute. 

Nicolás Fernández has been the class of the team in recent weeks with the displays he has produced. In three consecutive appearances, the 26-year-old attacking forward has cataloged a goal contribution. This term, the Argentine leads his side in this goal department, tallying nine goals through 14 league matches. 

Win a $5 Wager at FanDuel, Get $150 in Bonus Bets

Nashville SC vs. New York City FC - My Pick

• Nashville SC vs. New York City FC pick: Nashville SC ML three-way (-145) at FanDuel 

Now that Nashville bowed out of continental play with their focus set on MLS, they have looked sharper with the rest they are receiving, playing once a week. Geodis Park has so far been a fortress for the hosts, as they have secured five of six possible wins on home soil and scored 21 goals. We feel the hosts will overwhelm their opponent on Saturday, as NYCFC struggle to outperform opponents when playing away from home, having defeated teams ranked below them in the standings.

Yes, they can only play who they’re scheduled against, but NYCFC have yet to show they can hang with the more lethal sides in MLS. Plus, the visitors could be a bit fatigued, playing with a rotated lineup as they will be in midweek U.S. Open Cup action against the Columbus Crew.

Bet $5 at FanDuel, Get $150 in Bonus Bets if Your Bet Wins

How to Watch Nashville SC vs. New York City FC

• When: May 23, 8.30 pm ET 

• Where: Geodis Park

• TV: Apple TV