Best NHL Prop Bets Today | NHL Player Props, May 19

Dallas Stars vs Vegas Golden Knights

Jamie Benn U 0.5 Assists -165 (BetMGM)

The Dallas Stars will take on the Vegas Golden Knights in the first game of the Western Conference Finals. The Stars beat the Seattle Kraken in the Second Round, and the Golden Knights beat the Oilers. Dallas’ Jamie Benn will be the subject of our first prop bet of the day. Benn had an excellent regular season and finished with 78 points. He has taken that success into the Playoffs but was stifled in the final two games of the Second Round. I do not expect Benn to turn it around today. He will finish this game without an assist. Bet on the under.

Benn is a gifted player but is coming off a couple of bad games. The veteran may provide value to the Stars later on in the series, but he will struggle today. It is also worth noting that Benn will probably be on the ice for less than 16 minutes, so he will not have that many opportunities to have an assist. Bet on the under.

Dallas Stars vs Vegas Golden Knights

Tyler Seguin U 0.5 Points -135 (BetMGM)

Our second prop bet of the day will involve the Stars’ Tyler Seguin. Seguin played really well in the First Round but slowed down quite a bit in the Second Round. I do not see this changing in this game, and I expect him to finish without a point. Bet on the under.

Seguin only has one point (an assist) in his previous five games. In addition, he faced the Golden Knights three times this season and only had one goal. I only say this to show that the Golden Knights’ defensemen have his number and know how to slow him down. Seguin will struggle on the offensive end and not have a point. Bet on the under.

Dallas Stars vs Vegas Golden Knights

Max Domi O 1.5 Shots on Goal -130 (BetMGM)

Our final prop bet of the day will involve the Stars’ Max Domi. I did not intentionally pick only Stars’ players, yet here we are. Domi was traded from the Chicago Blackhawks to the Stars at the Trade Deadline. He underperformed in the regular season for Dallas but has stepped it up in the Playoffs. Domi has not scored much, but he does have eight assists. However, I expect him to be aggressive in this game and put up at least two shots. Bet on the over.

Domi is averaging 1.62 shots per game in the Playoffs. That is not a lot of shots, but Domi will want to take a different approach today and set the tone early.  That means he will be less hesitant to shoot. I do not expect him to lead the Stars in shots, but I expect him to have three or four. Bet on the over.