Best Steelers vs. Colts Prop Bets: Quarterbacks Set for Big Games

• The Colts are a 2.5-point favorite against the Steelers

• Indianapolis is coming off a dominant win over the Titans

• Aaron Rodgers is third in passing touchdowns with 16

The Colts enter Week 9 as slight favorites over the Steelers, and this game should be defined by offense. Aaron Rodgers and Daniel Jones can both throw the ball down the field, and this should lead to points. 

I have picked three props for the matchup on Fanatics Sportsbook. All three of the picks revolve around the passing game.

Best Steelers vs. Colts Prop Bets

I have three player props from Fanatics Sportsbook for you to consider. Sign up for a Fanatics account today and receive $100 in FanCash instantly after wagering your first $10 bet. Also, check our top-rated prop betting sites.

If you're in a state where Fanatics Sportsbook is not yet legal, we recommend playing at Kalshi. See how to claim your Kalshi Referral Code WSN and sign up below.

Daniel Jones Over 1.5 Passing Touchdowns (-115) at Fanatics Sportsbook

Daniel Jones is quietly putting together one of his more efficient seasons as a pro. Many people wrote him off after a rough beginning to his career in New York. 

He was an interception machine, and he didn’t look like he was worthy of being a starting quarterback in the NFL. This is far from the truth, and he has proven it through the first half of his season with the Colts. 

He has now thrown multiple touchdown passes in four straight starts. The Steelers’ secondary has been inconsistent, and they allow the most passing yards per game in the NFL. 

The Colts have an elite play action game, which leads to a lot of wide-open receivers. Jones has stretched the field vertically, and this is something that results in passing touchdowns. 

Jones has shown better poise in the pocket behind improved protection, and his chemistry with his receivers looks unmatched. The biggest case for Jones surpassing 1.5 touchdowns through the air is his offensive line. 

Jones has so much time to throw the ball, and this is why he has looked like an MVP quarterback.

Bet $10, Get $100 in FanCash Instantly at Fanatics

Aaron Rodgers Over 233.5 Passing Yards (-115) at Fanatics Sportsbook

Aaron Rodgers has looked sharp in his first season with the Steelers. He threw for 219 yards and two scores last week. He’s now averaging 212 passing yards per game this season, but he will need to throw in this contest to keep pace with the Colts. 

Indianapolis has one of the best offenses in the league, so Rodgers must throw the ball to stay in the game. The Colts' secondary is strong, but Rodgers should hit this number on bulk alone. 

Rodgers should be able to exploit Indianapolis's zone-heavy coverage, especially with time in the pocket. The Steelers' offensive line has been stout, and they should have another great game on Sunday. 

Expect Rodgers to take several deep shots early, particularly to DK Metcalf. With both defenses capable of forcing turnovers, game flow should favor plenty of passing volume for Rodgers to comfortably clear this total.

Sign Up at Fanatics and Claim $100 in FanCash Instantly

Michael Pittman Over 52.5 Receiving Yards (-115) at Fanatics Sportsbook

Michael Pittman has been a model of consistency this season. He has 43 receptions for 446 yards and six touchdowns on the season. 

The Steelers' passing defense has been horrendous in 2025, and Pittman has the skillset to take advantage of their players. 

His average depth of target increased drastically last week, and this trend should continue against Pittsburgh. 

With Jones' pocket presence, Pittman should continue his steady production as the focal point of the passing attack and go over his line. 

Pittsburgh is at home in this contest, which is our one fear taking props for Indianapolis. The Colts may struggle early in the game, but they should find consistency by the second quarter.

Bet $10 at Fanatics and Get $100 in FanCash Instantly

More NFL Week 9 Stories

• NFL Odds Week 9

• Commanders vs Seahawks Same Game Parlay SNF Week 9

• Commanders vs. Seahawks Prop Bets SNF Week 9

• Anytime Touchdown Scorer Predictions in Week 9