Best NHL Prop Bets Today: NHL Prop Picks for May 9
wsn-newsletter Subscribe to WSN.

Best NHL Prop Bets Today: Expect an Uptick in Scoring Between Dallas and Winnipeg

Published: May. 9, 2025, 03:56 AM ET
5 min read

With both defenses struggling since the start of the playoffs, expect an uptick in scoring between Dallas and Winnipeg in game two of their series. Before their puck drops, we target a team total in the matchup between Toronto and Florida as the reigning Stanley Cup champions face off against a Maple Leafs back line who grades out poorly in Expected Goals Against in All Situations.

Odds courtesy of BetMGM Sportsbook. Get up to $1,500 back in the form of bonus bets should you lose your first wager after creating an account with the WSN promo code WSNSPORTS.

How We Rate
Affiliate Disclaimer
21+
Best NHL Prop Bets Today May 9

Dallas Stars vs. Winnipeg Jets - Prop Bets (9:30 PM, EST)

Alternate Full Game Over 6.5 (+125) at BetMGM Sportsbook

The Winnipeg Jets regression on defense has been one of the bigger storylines since the start of the playoffs as Connor Hellebuyck has struggled to give them the individual production they need to remain competitive in their contests. In his eight starts, the reigning Vezina Trophy winner is averaging an astonishing 3.75 Goals Against per game. A sharp contrast from his regular season performance as he finished the year leading the league with an average of 2.01 and a Save Percentage of .925.

A stunning low level of play from Hellebuyck, especially when factoring in how good his back line has played as the Jets defense currently ranks second overall in Expected Goals Against in All Situations. Even though they have managed to play well, regression also looms large over the Presidents’ Trophy winners defense as the Stars versatility has had no issue with stretching out their coverage to help set up high quality Shots on Goal. In game one of their series, the Stars generated an Expected Goal of 3.19.

Fortunately for Winnipeg, their offense will have the opportunity to match the Stars scoring pace as they face off against a back line who ranks 17th overall in Expected Goals Against in All Situations with an average of 3.09 Expected Goals Against per game. Their lack of coverage leaves their net exposed to high quality shot attempts which drastically increases the Jets chances of scoring. Place a full size wager on the over of 5.5 and escalator bet the full game total by sprinkling smaller wagers on the alternate totals.

Claim $1,500 in Bonus Bets at BetMGM

Mikko Rantanen Anytime Goalscorer (+175) at FanDuel Sportsbook

After being held scoreless in the first four games of the playoffs, Mikko Rantanen has caught fire as the Stars forward has scored eight goals in his last four outings. Since joining Dallas at the trade deadline, Rantanen has had no issue with sustaining his high level of play in his new home as the Stars forward averages 0.44 Expected Goals per game. With Winnipeg struggling to provide Hellebuyck the coverage he needs to round back into form, expect Rantanen to find the back of the net for the fifth game in a row.

Get $200 in Bonus Bets at FanDuel With a $5 Winning Wager

Toronto Maple Leafs vs. Florida Panthers - Prop Bets (7:00 PM, EST)

Florida Panthers Team Total Over 3.5 (-115) at BetMGM Sportsbook

After opening up as the betting favorite on the series moneyline, the script has flipped on the reigning Stanley Cup champions as the Florida Panthers are now 0-2 against Toronto in the conference semifinals. Even though their defense has struggled to wall off Toronto’s front line, their own offense has still played quite well as they currently lead the Maple Leafs in Expected Goals and are averaging 3.44 Expected Goals For in All Situations since the start of the playoffs.

Their offense will have a great opportunity to round back into form in game three as they face off against a Maple Leafs defense who has struggled mightily in coverage this season. As of writing, Toronto’s back line ranks 22nd overall in Expected Goals Against in All Situations. Even with Anthony Stolarz giving them a high level of individual production in their net, the Maple Leafs goaltender will be under a heavy amount of pressure while consistently shifting across the crease in an attempt to wall off Florida’s spread out attack.

BetMGM $1,500 First Bet with Code WSNSPORTS

Matthew Tkachuk Anytime Goalscorer (+165) at FanDuel Sportsbook

It has been a quiet series for Matthew Tkachuk as the Panthers forward has failed to score a goal in his two games against Toronto. Even though he failed to score, Tkachuk has still excelled at pressuring the net as he finished game two with an Expected Goal of 0.59. Expect positive regression to swing towards his way, especially with the Maple Leafs struggling to defend their net as their low mark in Expected Goals Against in All Situations indicates.

Bet $5, Get $200 in Bonus Bets if Your Bet Wins

tip_r

Responsible Gambling

If you or someone you know needs support or wants to speak with a professional about responsible gambling, seek out the correct resources. Call or text 1-800-GAMBLER to get help, or visit 1800gambler.net for more information. WSN is an advocate for safe gambling practices. Visit our Responsible Gambling Center for more details.

Kody Malstrom WSN Contributor

Kody Malstrom

Sports Betting Analyst

Expertise:
MLB
NHL
Betting Picks
Kody Malstrom is a sports betting journalist with six years of writing experience in the industry. He covers an abundance of sports, including College Football, NFL, College Basketball, NBA, and more. Born and raised in Michigan, Kody is a devoted Detroit Sports fan and spends his Sundays rooting for the Detroit Lions while telling himself this year is the year they win it all. When not staring at betting markets, Kody spends his free time at the beach in the summer or snowboarding in the winter.
Email: [email protected]
Nationality: American
Education: Bachelor of Finance
Favourite Sportsbook: Caesars Sportsbook
Favourite Casino: BetMGM Casino
Experience: 6 years
We've been featured on:
espn logo
reuters logo
cbs-news logo
forbes logo
entrepreneur logo
entrepreneur logo
We only list licensed sportsbooks

We support responsible gambling. Gambling can be addictive, please play responsibly. If you need help, call 1-800-Gambler.

WSN.com is managed by Gentoo Media. Unless declared otherwise, all of the visible content on this site, such as texts and images, including the brand name and logo, belongs to Innovation Labs Limited (a Gentoo Media company) - Company Registration Number C44130, VAT ID: MT18874732, @GIG Beach Triq id-Dragunara, St. Julians, STJ3148, Malta.

Advertising Disclosure: WSN.com contains links to partner websites. When a visitor to our website clicks on one of these links and makes a purchase at a partner site, World Sports Network is paid a commission.

Copyright © 2025