Best Tetairoa McMillan Player Props for Panthers vs. Buccaneers in Week 16

• The Panthers and Buccaneers are tied for first place in the NFC South

• This is the first of two meetings between the teams 

• Tet McMillan has 59 catches and six touchdowns this season

The battle for the NFC South will come down to the final three weeks of the season. Carolina has exceeded expectations in 2025, and a significant reason they’re in the hunt is their receiver, Tatairao McMillan. 

I expect there to be plenty of points in this game, which will keep McMillan heavily involved in the offense. I have selected three player props for McMillan on Sunday.

Best Tetairoa McMillan Player Props for Panthers vs. Buccaneers

Odds provided by bet365, one of our top-rated prop betting sites. Sign up for a bet365 account today with our promo code WSN365 and get $150 in bonus bets. Read our bet365 review and learn how to claim your bet365 sportsbook promo code.

If you're in a state where bet365 Sportsbook is not yet legal, we recommend playing at Underdog. Read our Underdog Review and sign up below with our promo code WSNPLAY.

Tetairoa McMillan Over 3.5 Receptions (-115) at bet365

McMillan has put together an impressive rookie campaign, though his involvement has dipped over the last few weeks. That should change in this matchup, as Carolina will need him to play a significant role offensively. 

McMillan has 59 catches, which ranks 37th in the NFL. While he hasn’t cleared this line in his last three games, this feels like a spot where the Panthers make a concerted effort to get him more involved against Tampa Bay.

Early in the season, McMillan was heavily targeted, and Carolina was winning games during that stretch. If the Panthers want to stay in the NFC South race, this is a must-win game, and that starts with McMillan delivering a standout performance.

McMillan’s versatility only helps this prop. He’s used on quick screens, short routes, and intermediate throws, giving him multiple paths to reach four receptions. 

I expect Carolina to establish the run early, which should open things up for McMillan downfield and allow this prop to cash.

Bet $5 at bet365 and Get $150 in Bonus Bets

Tetairoa McMillan Over 56.5 Receiving Yards (-115) at bet365

If McMillan clears his receptions prop, it’s reasonable to expect him to cash his receiving yards as well. This number is suppressed due to his recent production, but this sets up as an ideal bounce-back spot.

McMillan has totaled 851 receiving yards in 2025, ranking 16th in the NFL. He hasn’t surpassed 57 receiving yards in his last three games, which makes this an attractive buy-low opportunity.

He’s gone over this line in seven games this season, so the task is very manageable. The Buccaneers rank 30th in the league against the pass, and that matchup strongly favors McMillan in this spot.

Carolina has done a great job keeping defenses off balance all season, and I expect more of the same in Week 16. Tampa Bay shouldn’t have an answer for McMillan, setting him up to go over 56.5 receiving yards.

Get $150 in Bonus Bets When Betting $5 at bet365

Tetairoa McMillan Anytime Touchdown (+165) at bet365

If McMillan delivers the type of performance I’m expecting, finding the end zone should come easy. He has six touchdowns on the season and is clearly a focal point for Carolina in the red zone.

The Buccaneers have been horrendous on defense lately, which gives the receiver a chance to make plays. 

McMillan has scored four touchdowns over his last four games, showing the Panthers’ trust in the rookie to finish drives. His ability to turn short plays into explosive gains makes him a constant scoring threat.

He’s recorded multi-touchdown games twice this season, against Dallas and Atlanta, and Tampa Bay profiles as a defense he can exploit similarly.

If Carolina scores through the air, McMillan is the most likely source. I expect him to be open throughout the game and create yards after the catch, a formula that should lead to a touchdown and cash this prop.

Claim $150 in Bonus Bets at bet365 With a $5 Wager

Tetairoa McMillan Stats

• Receptions: 59

• Receiving Yards: 851

• Touchdowns: 6

• Yards Per Catch: 14.1