Did Refs’ Big No-Call Cost New Orleans Saints the Super Bowl?
After what some are calling the biggest no-call in NFL history, referees are getting a tremendous amount of backlash for failing to throw an obvious helmet-to-helmet/pass interference flag during a clutch, fourth-quarter play in the NFC Conference Championship game last Sunday.
Across the board, players, coaches and media talking heads all seem to agree that the missed call was blatant, critical and yet another example of how the inherent limitations of NFL refereeing are affecting the outcome of too many professional football games.
Here, we answer some basic yet important questions about this frustrating and inexplicable no-call and check in on how the football world is reacting to something so blatantly unfair.
Exactly what happened with the no-call?
Heres the situation: the game was tied at 20 in the fourth quarter with under two minutes left on the clock, the Saints had the ball on the Rams 13-yard line and it was third-and-ten.
Saints quarterback Drew Brees got a pass off intended for wide receiver Tommylee Lewis who looked to be able to catch the ball near the sidelines.
But before the ball arrives, Los Angeles Rams cornerback Nickell Robey-Coleman launches into the picture, delivering a fierce helmet-to-helmet hit that prevents Lewis from staying vertical, let alone from catching the incoming ball.
How could the referee miss the call?
Thats the big mystery how could something so obvious to everyone watching the game be completely missed by the men whose main job is to notice such things.
Penalties like pass interference and helmet-to-helmet are considered judgment calls, so it can only be assumed that, according to the referees judgment, no foul occurred.
The refs appeared to be in position to see the penalty, but unwilling to make the call.
Did the no-call happen because the game was in the fourth quarter?
Sometimes referees will let the players play in the fourth quarter and purposely not throw a flag on close calls so that officiating doesnt dictate the outcome of games.
But when asked if the timing of the game might have had an impact on a no-call there, NFL head referee Bill Vinovich replied, Absolutely not.
Its ironic how the penalty no-call actually did end up dictating the outcome of the game.
Couldnt New Orleans Saints head coach Sean Payton have challenged the no-call?
Payton couldnt throw the challenge flag and have the booth review the play because, according to the NFL rules, its a non-reviewable play.
Had the refs called a penalty, would the Saints have won the game?
Had either of the two penalties, the helmet-to-helmet hit or the pass interference, been called, the result would have been a fifteen-yard penalty and an automatic first down with about 1:45 remaining on the clock.
The Saints could have knelt for three downs and let the clock run down to less than five seconds and then kicked the game winning field goal.
Then, even if there was any time left on the clock, the Rams would have had to manage a kickoff return and a touchdown in just one or two seconds which is incredibly difficult and unlikely.
So yes, had the refs called a penalty in this case, the Saints would have certainly won the Conference Championship game and gone on to the Super Bowl in Atlanta.
Does Lewis think a penalty should have been called?
Receiver Lewis would know more than anyone whether he was hit in the helmet before he had a legitimate chance to make a grab for the ball.
Lewis has no doubt in his mind that it was a penalty.
I saw the defender coming. He got up under me. I got up looking for a flag and didnt see one. It was a bad call.
Does Robey-Coleman deny that he committed the penalty?
First off, Robey-Coleman says that Lewis wasnt even his man to cover, but when he saw that he was about to catch the ball, he dove at Lewis to prevent the reception.
On Twitter, he was quoted as saying, Yes, I got there too early. I was beat, and I was trying to save the touchdown.
But according to Robey-Coleman, after the play the referee told him that his hit was legal since Drew Brees pass was tipped at the line of scrimmage.
Had it not been for the tipped ball, Robey-Coleman says he would have been called for the pass interference.
Interesting, but that still doesnt excuse the blatant no-call of what was clearly a helmet-to-helmet hit on a defenseless player.
What does the NFL head referee have to say about the no-call?
NFL head referee Bill Vinovich was interviewed by the press, but his responses only added to the frustration of football fans who felt the refs blew the call.
Regarding the no-call that the entire football world was reacting to, Vinovich reminds everyone that its a judgment call by the officials, but then inexplicably adds, I personally have not seen the play.
Well then, maybe the NFL should hire a head referee who has the time and interest to actually sit down and watch the Conference Championship games of the league hes in charge of officiating.
Has Saints head coach Sean Payton commented?
Yes, he did a presser after the game and, though obviously disappointed and upset, Payton was direct and showed class.
Said Payton: Obviously its a disappointing way to lose a game. Its frustrating.
When asked if the call had been blown, Payton didnt hesitate.
Just getting off the phone with the league office. They blew the call That call puts it first and 10. Were on our knee three plays [and kicking the field goal] and its a game changing call.
Has Drew Brees reacted to the no-call?
NFL players have to be careful with what they say about the refereeing because they can (and have been) fined for speaking negatively.
Quarterback Drew Brees showed his true sportsmanship by not blaming no-call for the loss, but still he had some words about it:
Yeah, thats tough to swallow Obviously in a situation like that where it seemed like everybody in the world saw it, its tough.
Has the Saints owner commented?
Yes, Saints owner Gayle Benson issued a statement on Monday.
In it, she said that her team was unfairly deprived of a chance to reach the Super Bowl.
Benson also declared her intention to aggressively pursue changes in NFL policies to ensure no team and fan base is ever put in a similar position again.
How did the Rams head coach Sean McVay react?
Rams head coach Sean McVays reaction after the game was what anyone whos on the good end of a bad call would be.
McVay told the media, I thought it was a bang-bang type play. The one thing I respect about the refs today is that they let the guys compete and they let the guys play.
Then he stated the obvious and said, Certainly Im not going to complain about the way that was officiated.
Did any Rams players react?
Rams running back Todd Gurley got a lot of attention from his Instagram post regarding the no-call.
It shows Gurley holding up a referees jersey posed next to a ref holding up a Gurley II jersey, as if they had just exchanged them, as is the tradition between players.
The photo drew instant ire from talking heads like New York radio host Mike Francesa, who was outraged, saying, Thats such a bad thing to do, number one. Number two, they have to stay distant from the players.
Except it turns out the picture was Photoshopped, but regardless the anger it caused was very real.
Have celebrities reacted to the no-call?
Harry Connick Jr.
Harry Connick Jr., a Louisiana native, immediately wrote a heartfelt yet furious letter to NFL commissioner Roger Goodell.
Connick pulls no punches, and at one point the letter reads, To not call the pass interference/helmet-to-helmet penalties at the end of the game was one of the most disgraceful no-calls I have ever seen.
And then Connick writes with eloquence the sentiment that seems to be flying through every football fans furious head:
it sickens me to know that the people who are assigned to fairly officiate the game seemingly had no regard for not only a dangerous penalty but one that would certainly have changed the outcome of the game.
NBA legend Lebron James chimed in on Twitter:
On another note. Them ?s be on some ?. Hate to see that happen in such a great game! ?????
LeBron James (@KingJames) January 20, 2019
Though actress Sandra Bullock didnt personally react to the big no-call, her now-famous blindfolded image in the movie Bird Box was used multiple times to represent the NFL refs who blew the call.
The ref on that last play. pic.twitter.com/KUYWtZgKju
Field Yates (@FieldYates) January 20, 2019
How has the football world reacted?
For the first time in NFL forever there doesnt seem to be a lot of disagreement on whether this no-call was a blown call.
Twitter lit up with furious tweets, and not just from angry Saints fans. Here are a few:
Wow, has to be one of the worst no calls Ive seen.
Kyle Emanuel (@KyleEmanuel51) January 20, 2019
This game should be over. Abominable no-call.
Doug Farrar (@NFL_DougFarrar) January 20, 2019
Committing PI so egregious that the ref didnt believe it could have been real is a good strategy
Matt Brown (@MattBrownCFB) January 20, 2019
And the angry Tweets truly go on and on
Has NFL commissioner Roger Goodell commented?
As of yesterday, Roger Goodell has remained silent about the missed call.
Since the league has already admitted the mistake to Payton, its assumed that at some point they will put out a public statement admitting to the flub.
Whats not clear is what the league intends to do about the Saints being deprived of their Super Bowl opportunity, but Saints wide receiver Michael Thomas has Tweeted a suggestion.
Michael Thomas interesting Tweet
Rule 17 Section 2 Article 3 @NFL ???
Michael Thomas (@Cantguardmike) January 21, 2019
Thomas is referring to where in the NFL rulebook it actually allows the league to reverse an outcome of a game affected by “unfair acts.”
The rule goes on to state that
if appropriate, the reversal of a games result or the rescheduling of a game, either from the beginning or from the point at which the extraordinary act occurred.
In other words, a do-over.
Could there be a do-over?
Unfortunately, the league has never used that rule to reverse the outcome of a game, so its not very likely to do that now.
Instead, a public apology will be issued and the Saints will be expected to forgive and go marching on.
But even Sports Illustrated has called on Goodell to use his almighty powers for good and allow a do-over in a Monday Tweet:
People in New Orleans will be playing what if for years, but it turns out Roger Goodell has the power to turn the hypothetical into reality https://t.co/ZpkkkLa9tJ
— Sports Illustrated (@SInow) January 21, 2019
Hard to imagine Goodell making this one right with an unprecedented do-over between the Rams and Saints, but with the entire city of New Orleans threatening to boycott the Super Bowl, anything is possible.
Football fans will just have to wait and see.