AL East Winner Odds & Predictions 2025: Blue Jays Lead Yankees Down the Stretch

• The Blue Jays are AL East favorites at -800

• Toronto has a two-game lead over New York

• Toronto will face Boston to start the week

The Toronto Blue Jays have maintained their AL East lead for most of the season and are closing in on a title. The Blue Jays will face the Red Sox this week, and they can clinch a title soon. 

The Red Sox and Yankees are still mathematically alive in the division race, but Toronto controls its destiny. Here, we will break down the AL East and give our best bet to win the title.

MLB AL East Winner Odds

Hard Rock Sportsbook is a great platform for baseball betting. Their welcome bonus can get your betting on the app started on a high note as well. 

New customers at Hard Rock can claim the following welcome offer today: Bet $5, Get $150 in Bonus Bets if You Win. No promo code is needed during registration.

MLB AL East Winner Predictions

The Toronto Blue Jays were the first team in the American League to clinch a postseason berth. Additionally, they can become the first team in the league to win their respective division title.

Toronto is up two games on New York with a critical series against Boston beginning on Tuesday. The Blue Jays have been excellent this season in all phases of the game, and it has caused them to become one of the favorites to win the American League and World Series.

The Blue Jays' AL East magic number is four as of Tuesday. The magic number is a combination of how many games they need to win and how many the Yankees need to lose.

Therefore, if they won two more games in the last week of the season, and New York lost two, they would reach their magic number of four games.

Toronto could also go 4-2 in their final six games, and New York could go undefeated, and they would still win the division because they hit their magic number.

The Blue Jays also hold the tiebreaker over the Yankees, which makes New York’s task of chasing down Toronto that much more challenging.

Toronto went 8-5 in 13 games against New York, so they have a lot of wiggle room over the final six games of the season.

Bet $5 at Hard Rock Bet and Claim $150 in Bonus Bets

MLB AL East Winner - My Pick

Boston Red Sox  (-800) at Hard Rock

If the Blue Jays don’t win the AL East at this point, it would be shocking. We expect them to clinch by Friday as they will face an injured Red Sox team and a struggling Rays club to end the year with all six games at home.

Wager $5 at Hard Rock and Claim $150 in Bonus Bets

How to Bet on the MLB AL East Winner

Watching the division's five teams is the first step to successfully betting on the AL East. When you consistently watch AL East baseball, it gives you the best information to place successful wagers. 

To bet on the AL East winner on FanDuel, go to the MLB section of the sportsbook. You can then go to the divisions section and find the odds for the AL East. 

If you want to take our projected winner, add the Red Sox to your bet slip when you go to the AL East odds section. Once you place money on the ticket, press confirm, and you’ll become a Boston fan as you sweat the bet throughout the year. 

The AL East odds change daily since teams play every day of the week. One win or loss can significantly change the odds, so it’s best to know how the teams typically perform in different times of the season. 

How to Read MLB AL East Winner Odds

The American odds may look slightly confusing if you’re new to sports betting. 

If the odds show a minus (–), then that amount must be wagered to win $100. (e.g., 150 means you must bet $150 to win $100.)

If the odds show a plus (+), you will earn that money on a successful $100 bet. (e.g. +150 means you make $150 on a $100 wager.)

If you bet $100 on the Yankees to win the AL East on FanDuel (+105), you would win $105 if they were successful. 

Where to Bet on the MLB AL East Winner

FanDuel Sportsbook is one of the best betting platforms for MLB, but it’s not the only game in town. There are many betting platforms where you can test your luck on the American League East. 

BetMGM Sportsbook is an excellent sportsbook for MLB betting. Their welcome bonus is one of the primary reasons for utilizing the platform. The company prides itself on catering to large bettors, and that’s why new customers can claim the following offer: Bet $10, Get $150 if You Win*. Use code WSNSPORTS at BetMGM to start today. 

*Bonus Bets Expire in 7 Days. One New Customer Offer Only. Add’l terms.

Caesars Sportsbook is an excellent sportsbook for prop betting. If you like MLB props, you should sign up for Caesars today. New customers on Caesars will receive this currently active offer: Bet $1, Double Your Winnings Next 20 Bets. Use promo code WSN20X to take advantage of this tremendous offer and get started on a high note for MLB betting. 

MLB AL East History

The AL East began in 1969 when the Orioles hoisted the division pennant. Baltimore won five of the first six seasons before their title victories became more sporadic. The Yankees then took over a stretch of dominance, winning five of six championships from 1976 to 1981.

The Yankees have been the best team in the AL East since 1969, with a division-leading 21 victories. They won the title in 2024 and weren’t stopped until the World Series, when they lost to the Dodgers. However, the Red Sox have won the most championships, with four since 2013.