MLB Cy Young Odds & Predictions 2025: Skenes and Wheeler are Locked Into a Two Horse Race

• Tarik Skubal’s odds to win the AL Cy Young award continues to grow

• Zack Wheeler and Paul Skenes are listed as the co-betting favorites for the NL Cy Young award

• The Pittsburgh Pirates defense ranks top-10 in Defensive Efficiency and in Fielding Percentage

The MLB has transformed into a pitchers league over the past couple of years as there are seemingly more elite pitchers than ever before who are capable of shutting down opposing offenses on a nightly basis. This movement has turned the race for the Cy Young awards into one of the more exciting spectacles in the sport as one successful or detrimental performance can make or break someone's chances of winning the award.

MLB Cy Young Award 2025 Odds

Odds courtesy of BetMGM. Use our promo code WSNSPORTS and claim the following promo at BetMGM: Get Up to $1,500 in Bonus Bets*. Check our BetMGM sportsbook review for more info.

*Bonus Bets Expire in 7 Days. One New Customer Offer Only. Add’l terms.

AL Cy Young Award Odds

NL Cy Young Award Odds

Cy Young Award Predictions

Even though Tarik Skubal’s odds to win the AL Cy Young award have continued to grow, Garrett Crochet has managed to remain in contention for the title as he is averaging just one Earned Run per game in the month of July. A high level of play that we have been accustomed to for the duration of the season as Crochet is also averaging an ERA of 2.19, a WHIP of 1.064, and a FIP of 2.41. If you bet on Skubal, then consider hedging some of your bet on Crochet.

In the NL, Paul Skenes and Zack Wheeler are locked into a two horse race for the Cy Young as both pitchers are listed as the co-betting favorites for the award as of writing. When comparing the two, Skenes has the edge over Wheeler in regard to ERA and in FIP while the Phillies ace possesses a lower WHIP and more Pitcher Wins. Skenes is also supported by a more productive defense as the Pittsburgh Pirates defense ranks top-3 in Defensive Efficiency.

Claim $1,500 in Bonus Bets at BetMGM

MLB Cy Young Winner - My Pick

Tarik Skubal (-285) at BetMGM

After underwhelming in the MLB All Star game, Tarik Skubal has managed to quickly round back into form as he held the Texas Rangers to just four Hits and one Earned Run while generating 11 total Strikeouts. His latest performance helped chip away at Garrett Crochet’s lead for the most Strikeouts in the league while playing in one less game. With his defense playing at a high level, expect Skubal to continue to thrive and run away with the Cy Young award.

Claim $1,500 Bonus Offer at BetMGM

How to Bet on the MLB Cy Young Winner

The Cy Young award market is one of the more volatile betting markets in the sport as one successful or poor outing can drastically shake up the oddsboard. In order to be successful and make a profit betting on the award, you need to build a diverse portfolio and place wagers on pitchers who are in a position to strengthen their claim for the award before doing so.

Whether that is throwing some darts on some long shots before the season starts and hedging out them when a favorite gets off to a hot start, or vice versa, you will need to consistently keep an eye on the market to take advantage of the best possible odds. In Tarik Skubal’s case, place a wager on him now and look to create multiple outs as the season progresses.

How to Read MLB Cy Young Odds

When placing any sort of wager, it’s important to understand how the listed odds work. If you bet on Tarik Skubal to win the Cy Young award at his preseason odds of +450, then a $100 wager would profit you $100 if he wins the award.

If you wait to see if he gets off to a hot start and is listed with a minus sign in front of his odds (-125 for example), then you would need to wager $125 to win $100. Placing wagers at the best available odds will help you churn a profit over the long run, making it vital you consistently check the market for potential hedge opportunities.

Where to Bet on the MLB Cy Young Winner

BetMGM Sportsbook has been one of the better apps to use when betting on the Cy Young award, as they usually beat out the rest of the apps in terms of best available odds. If you do not already have an account with BetMGM, you can use our promo code WSNSPORTS and claim the following offer: Get Up to $1,500 in Bonus Bets.

As for the official betting partner of the MLB, FanDuel Sportsbook is giving an opportunity to new users to claim: Bet $5, Get $150 in Bonus Bets if Your Bet Wins.
No promo code is required to take advantage of this offer; you just need to create an account and win your first wager of at least $5 on any valid FanDuel market.

MLB Cy Young AL & NL MVP Winner History

After winning the 2024 AL Cy Young award, Tarik Skubal has the opportunity to be the first pitcher to win the title in two straight years since Jacob deGrom did it back in 2018-2019. If Skubal does win the pitching title this season, then the Tigers' ace would be just the 23rd player in the history of the MLB to win more than one Cy Young award.

Unfortunately for Skubal, he will still have some catching up to do if he wants to lead the league for the most Cy Young award,s as Roger Clemens currently leads all pitchers with seven total titles. Clemens was as consistent as it gets as he never won the award more than twice in a row while racking up the titles from 1986 until his last one in 2004.

AL Cy Young Award Winners

NL Cy Young Award Winners