NFL Comeback Player of the Year 2025: McCaffrey New Favorite, Jones Soars

• Dallas Cowboys QB Dak Prescott, who opened as the favorite, is now second

• Daniel Jones skyrocketed in odds after a great Week 1 showing

• Quarterbacks won more than 59 percent of all Comeback Player of the Year awards

The NFL Comeback Player of the Year is awarded annually to a player who overcomes personal adversity and reminds the world of what hard work and determination can do. Sportsbooks have updated their odds for who they believe are in the best position to win the 2025 Comeback Player of the Year award.

Comeback Player of the Year 2025 Odds

Odds from BetMGM Sportsbook. Use our promo code WSNSPORTS to sign up for a BetMGM account and claim: Bet $10, Get $150 if You Win*.

*Bonus Bets Expire in 7 Days. One New Customer Offer Only. Add’l terms.

*21+ only. Please Gamble Responsibly. See BetMGM.com for Terms. First Bet Offer for new customers only (if applicable). Subject to eligibility requirements.

Comeback Player of the Year Predictions

The Comeback Player of the Year award is tough to predict since it has less positional value than the MVP and Offensive and Defensive Player of the Year honors. Dak Prescott figures to put up the best stats since he’s the best quarterback on the list, but that doesn’t mean he will have pulled off a better comeback than a player such as Daniel Jones.

One thing’s for sure, McCaffrey is an incredibly risky pick. There’s little value to be had, and he’s a constant injury risk. Deebo Samuel is an interesting pick due to his projected usage in Washington, although quarterbacks have dominated this award market.

Sign Up at BetMGM and Claim Your Bonus

Comeback Player of the Year Winner - My Pick

• Aidan Hutchinson (+350) at BetMGM Sportsbook

Hutchinson was completely shut out in Week 1, but the Lions as a whole didn’t come ready to play against the Packers. The value is firmly on his shoulders among the top favorites, and he’s still an outstanding player who was going to run away with the DPOY trophy last year until he suffered an injury. Daniel Jones looks like the best longshot pick so long as Shane Steichen continues to prove himself as a brilliant offensive mind.

Claim Your Welcome Offer at BetMGM

How to Bet on the Comeback Player of the Year

There’s no league more popular for American sports bettors than the NFL. Every sportsbook should have a section dedicated to the NFL, and the Comeback Player of the Year odds, if available, should be listed under the “Futures” section. 

Futures bets are different from major markets in that they pertain to long-term events. In the case of the Comeback Player of the Year, the winner won’t be announced until the year-end player awards.

Certain states do not allow individual player futures bets, which would eliminate them from providing odds on the NFL Comeback Player of the Year. Check your state’s rules and sportsbook to see if your state qualifies.

How to Read Comeback Player of the Year Odds

Reading Comeback Player of the Year odds is the same as reading odds in any other market. Odds values preceded by a + indicate that a bettor will win the listed amount with a $100 wager—for example, a winning wager at +400 odds will result in a $400 profit for a $100 bet.

Conversely, odds values led by a - imply that a bettor must risk the listed amount to win $100. So, -550 odds suggest a bettor must wager $550 to profit $100.

Where futures odds can be different from limited-outcome markets is that the favorite is not always or even usually indicated by a negative odds value. The more candidates there are, the more likely it is that all outcomes have positive odds, especially early in the NFL season.

Where to Bet on Comeback Player of the Year Winner

As we mentioned, the NFL is the most popular sports league in America. NFL betting, including a variety of futures markets, should be available at every reputable sportsbook.

For this piece, we have used odds from Caesars Sportsbook. It's a great choice for NFL betting, and sports betting in general. Their odds are posted and refreshed timely, you can find odds boost and new users are eligible for a generous welcome offer: Bet $1, Double Your Winnings Next 20 Bets. Just don't forget to use our promo code WSN20X during the sign-up process.

As an alternative, have a look at FanDuel Sportsbook. FanDuel is among the most popular sportsbooks available in the US and offers a great selection of NFL bets, so you should be covered throughout the season. New users who sign up for a new account through our link will get the following offer: Bet $5, Get $300 in Bonus Bets if Your Bet Wins. No promo code is necessary.

Comeback Player of the Year Winner History (Since 2000)